Not surprisingly, Matt Vinc dominates both of these lists - for and against the Bandits. He broke the "record" for the Bandits in twice in the 2023 playoffs, breaking his own record in the championship final. The first list is for Buffalo goalies:
Name - Opponent - Date - Saves/Shots - Pct.
Vinc - Colorado - 6/3/23 - 46/50 - .920
Vinc - Toronto - 5/12/23 - 52/57 - .912
Vinc - Albany - 5/17/22 - 45/50 - .900
Vinc - New England - 5/14/19 - 46/52 - .885
Cosmo - Toronto - 5/5/12 - 48/55 - .873
Vinc - 5/6/23 - 44/51 - .863
Montour - Boston - 5/2/09 - 47/55 - .855
Thompson - Minnesota - 4/22/07 - 38/45 - .844
Vinc - Toronto - 5/11/19 - 43/51 - .843
Dietrich - Minnesota - 4/23/06 - 49/59 - .831
And while we are at it, we can look at opposing goalies. Someone must play at least 45 minutes to qualify, and Vinc has that record too:
Name - Opponent - Date - Saves/Shots - Pct.
Vinc - New York - 5/9/09 - 41/44 - .932
Del Bianco - Calgary - 5/18/19 - 48/55 - .873
Ward - Colorado - 6/18/22 - 55/63 - .873
Jamieson - Albany - 5/7/22 - 49/57 - .860
Rose - Toronto - 5/5/12 - 36/42 - .857
Ward - Colorado - 6/11/22 - 40/48 - .833
Bold - Saskatchewan - 5/28/16 - 43/52 - .827
Bold - Saskatchewan - 6/4/16 - 47/57 - .825
Nash - Colorado - 5/13/06 - 41/50 - .820
Jamieson - New England - 5/4/19 - 46/57 - .807
Updated as of June 4, 2023